I think it should be based on the MY Skins page, but that is only one mans opinion.

I thought of a way to quasi fix it to be a mash up of both styles...  I'll try to implement it on Monday, will take more time.

There has to be some other way of doing this. Having a cookie to track comments kept on a users local PC is just not going to work. If they clear there cookies they have to re-initiate one for each of their submissions? Over and over again? Or if they want to check the site from a different computer, they have to create cookies on it to track their comments? Come on now, maybe try talking to other programmers, there has to be another way.  I know my site and vStyler's (I maintain both), track new comments, forum posts, everything.  It tracks it in a different way, but maybe if you talk to someone over at e107.org they might be able to help you out with some coding changes.  The way of talking about doing it is just not going to work at all.  All you will have is a lot of complaining users.

I'm with you, Barb. You bringin' the milk? I got Oreos and Oatmeal-Raisin!

If you can just set it up so that I get an email notification when anyone leaves a comment on any one of my submissions that will be all I'd need.  I have close to 400 uploads and I really have no desire to have to go visit them all over again.

And this really doesn't seem to be working. I've visited my newer submissions numerous times for comments and have always found some but there was no "flag" letting me know they were there except for just now when "I" left a comment...then it showed a flag...letting me know "I" left a comment...but nothing for the previous 3 comments I found on my own.

On a side note...the thing I don't understand is the way it was set up before worked great...someone leaves a comment...you simply get notified by email...comment is replied to...done...why is that no longer doable? 

If there is no cookie for the skin, couldn't you just make one based on the My Skins page for all of the no-cookie skins, and then update the cookies individually as they are visited (like it is now)?

I'm still not getting anything on this skins page regarding comments. And I've been to the skins already checking comments.

So if anyone reading this leaves a comment and I don't reply your not being ignored...I just have no way of knowing you were there anymore.

same here, worked one time, now isn't

this is what I'm planning on doing...  having some issues with cookies expiring quicker than desired though that I have to iron out first (this is the cause of the page not working sometimes)

Are we ever going to have the comments notification thing working again like we once did? I used to work flawlessly and now it doesn't work at all. I still have to go and look if any comments were left. I really don't understand how something that worked great before can't be made to work like it did before.

New comments are working fine for me WG, hopefully someone in support can fix your problem, and your login issue too.

I think I got the log in issues fixed myself...but I still don't see any new comments being listed on the "My Skins" page and I guess email notifications aren't working yet either. And the longer things aren't working on the site the more I'm just losing interest.

Look at it this way WG, Stardock is the only place left both creates and supports their products in desktop customizing, there is no one else around in my opinion.  I must say they have made a vast amount of improvements since they switched over to the new site permanently, and I am sure they will have things ironed out within the next few months. Look at it this way, it can't get any worse at least! 

I'll stick around for a while... 

I'll be here as well Tom...just not as much as I used to be...it drains me waiting for things to load and annoying when things aren't working the way they used to is all.